Views from social work students on remote learning

By Student Voice

Introduction

The transition to remote learning, particularly for social work students, has been a significant shift marked by both opportunities and obstacles. Triggered by the global health crisis due to COVID-19, educational institutions, including those specialising in social work, found themselves starting a new process of online learning. This change was not just a case of moving classes from physical to digital formats but rethinking how interactive and practical learning could continue effectively in a quiet remote setting. Social work education, deeply rooted in direct human interaction and practical involvement, faces unique challenges under these conditions. Key among these is preserving the quality of education and maintaining student engagement. Student surveys and text analysis have highlighted worries about reduced practical experience and the struggle to adapt to new learning technologies. Listening to the student voice has been crucial in adapting courses to better fit the remote learning model, ensuring that critical aspects of social work training are not lost in translation to an online format. As we look into the implications of sustained remote education on social work, it is important to note the balance that must be struck between technological convenience and educational effectiveness.

Financial Concerns

Financial implications for students have been notably intensified by the shift to remote learning. The key concern highlighted by social work students is the continuation of high tuition fees despite the switch to online classes. This issue raises important questions about the fairness and value of education costs under these new circumstances. On the one hand, institutions may argue that the quality of tuition remains unchanged, necessitating existing fee structures. Conversely, students are undeniably facing economic strains, exacerbated by the higher costs associated with setting up and maintaining a suitable home study environment. The increased cost of living, notably in areas such as home utilities and internet bills, adds another layer of financial pressure. It is essential to look at whether bursaries and financial aids are reflective of these changes. While some argue that students should benefit from reductions in fees, others believe that institutions are also grappling with increased operational costs in the digital area. A balanced view suggests that a re-evaluation of fee structures and financial aid programmes is important to ensure they are adapted suitably to current student needs without uncompromising the institutions' ability to provide high-quality education.

Impact on Practical Experience

The shift to remote learning has notably altered the landscape for social work students, particularly in the area of practical experience. Social work, inherently reliant on direct human engagement and on-site learning opportunities, faces significant hurdles in an online-only setting. Students have expressed concerns about the challenges of securing placements with organisations less familiar with remote supervision. Furthermore, reduced face-to-face interaction can hamper the development of key skills necessary for effective social work, such as empathy, communication, and real-time problem-solving. On one hand, the use of virtual simulations and online case studies has been a useful stopgap. However, these methods lack the immediacy and nuanced dynamics of in-person interactions. It is important to consider how these changes might affect the students' readiness for professional roles. Text analysis of feedback and course evaluations suggest that while remote learning offers theoretical knowledge, the gap in hands-on practice remains a significant issue. Institutions might need to rethink how to integrate effective practical experiences into the remote curriculum, potentially through enhanced partnerships with local organisations that can offer remote internships or virtual field experiences.

Accommodation for Diverse Student Needs

The adaptation to remote learning has revealed gaps in addressing the wide-ranging needs of social work students, particularly those with caring responsibilities or health concerns. Recorded lectures, a seemingly simple solution, offer great benefits by providing flexibility in learning pace and timings that suit varied student schedules. Access to archived course materials can significantly aid students who need to revisit complex topics or who miss sessions due to unforeseen circumstances. On one hand, these resources allow students who juggle multiple responsibilities to manage their studies more effectively. Conversely, there is a perceived lack of immediate support and customisation of learning experiences that can arise from reliance on pre-recorded content. While some students find asynchronous learning tools beneficial, others struggle without the real-time interaction and tailored support that live classes offer. Institutions must therefore strive to strike a delicate balance, ensuring that while the technological tools used in remote learning make education accessible, they also need to maintain active engagement and support mechanisms that cater to the diverse needs of all students, including those with specific educational needs. This approach can ensure that no student is disadvantaged in their educational journey.

Positive Aspects of Remote Learning

{'content': 'With the transition to remote learning, many social work students have identified clear benefits to this mode of study. The flexibility offered by attending lectures from home is one positive aspect frequently highlighted. This arrangement can particularly assist those balancing studies with personal responsibilities. Accessibility improvements are also notable, as students can engage with course material from any location, lengthening the opportunity for learning to those who might have otherwise faced geographical or commuting barriers. \n\nThe process has also led to many students reporting enhanced availability of tutors and staff, fostering better interaction and timely support. Remote learning environments demand an evolution in teaching strategies, where staff have focused on more personalised feedback and accessible office hours through digital platforms. This shift has demonstrated that with careful planning and open communication, the educational process can remain rigorous and supportive, even outside the traditional classroom setting. These adjustments not only help in maintaining academic standards but also encourage a culture of inclusivity and adaptability, key traits for future social workers in their professional development.'}

The Case for Hybrid Learning

The preference for a hybrid learning model among social work students underscores a key insight: combining online learning with in-person interaction can enrich their educational experience significantly. This mixed approach addresses the need for flexibility from remote learning while retaining the essential face-to-face engagement crucial in social work education. On one hand, the ability to access lectures and resources online at any time supports students who manage complex schedules or face commuting barriers. Conversely, maintaining regular in-person classes ensures that students can still engage in the vital real-time discussions and practical exercises that are central to mastering social work competencies.

Text analysis of student feedback has highlighted a general appreciation for the adaptability that hybrid models offer, particularly when managing the demands of theoretical knowledge and practical application. Institutions looking to implement effective hybrid learning should focus on the integration of technology that supports both live and asynchronous interactions. Such a strategy not only makes learning more accessible but also maintains the quality of personal interaction and supervision that is fundamental to social work training. By adopting this balanced approach, educational institutions can better support social work students in their process to become proficient professionals.

Conclusion

In summary, the input from social work students about their remote learning experiences has provided key insights into both the merits and pitfalls of digital education. To enhance the success of remote learning, institutions must consider a range of improvements. Better organised course deliveries, along with more structured and engaging communication, could significantly alleviate student concerns about isolation and confusion. Additionally, addressing student feedback on accommodating diverse needs through more inclusive teaching methods and scheduled support could further refine the learning experience. Suggestions for future steps include refining the tools and platforms used, ensuring they are user-friendly and capable of supporting a diverse student body effectively. Exploring innovative ways to simulate practical experiences or partnering with organisations for virtual internships could also compensate for the reduced face-to-face interaction, which is particularly key in training competent social workers. As educational institutions continue adapting, it remains essential to maintain a constant dialogue with students to ensure that their needs and educational standards are met comprehensively. Looking ahead, these adjustments promise to make remote learning a more effective, inclusive, and supportive environment for all social work students.

Views from social work students on remote learning

More posts on remote learning:

More posts on social work student views: