Perspectives on feedback in media studies education

By Student Voice
feedbackmedia studies

Introduction

In the teaching of media studies within UK higher education, understanding the feedback received by students is key. This introductory section sets the stage for a deeper look at how media studies students perceive and utilise the feedback on their academic work. From their thoughts and feelings about the timing and clarity to the quality and consistency of the feedback, every aspect has an important role in shaping their educational experience and development. Analysing feedback from the student's perspective involves exploring different sources such as student surveys, where they express their views, and applying text analysis techniques to gauge a broader understanding. This approach aids in highlighting common trends and individual experiences that could inform better practices within the academic staff. This exploration is not merely academic; it has real-world implications on how students engage with the learning process and their overall academic journey in media studies. By looking into these varied feedback experiences, institutions can start a process that aligns academic expectations with student needs, fostering a more supportive and effective learning environment.

Feedback Timeliness

When discussing the timeliness of feedback, it's important to understand its influence on the learning outcomes of media studies students. Meeting the deadlines for giving feedback helps students promptly absorb and apply suggestions to subsequent tasks, such as module assignments or group projects. One key finding from student surveys is their discomfort with delayed feedback, which often means missing the chance to improve before their next assessment. For example, receiving feedback past the preferable 15-day window can lead to increased anxiety and reduced opportunity for academic development. Rapid feedback isn't just a preference; it has become an important expectation among students. Addressing this expectation can encourage a more active and engaged learning process. It's also clear from discussions with students that timely feedback encourages a more positive academic experience, leading to more focused and enthusiastic learners. Staff within media studies departments should thus look at strategies to ensure that feedback is not only swift but also meaningful, helping students leverage their learning effectively within the timeframe of their courses.

Feedback Clarity

In the area of feedback clarity, media studies students have expressed that understanding the guidance provided by their assessors is absolutely important for their academic growth. When feedback is clear and constructive, students find it easier to recognise where they excel and where improvements are necessary. However, a common concern among students is feedback that contains vague or overly general comments, which fails to give them a clear direction on how to enhance their work or understand academic standards. This becomes particularly challenging when assignments often require a high level of creativity and critical thinking, typical in media studies courses. To address these concerns, staff need to ensure that their feedback is not only transparent but also directly applicable to the tasks at hand. Simple strategies, such as using straightforward language and providing specific examples, can dramatically improve the clarity of feedback. Engaging students in feedback sessions where they can ask questions and seek further clarification also supports a deeper understanding and appreciation of the feedback process. Institutions teaching media studies should thus prioritise clear communication to boost students' confidence and academic performance.

Feedback Quality

When looking at feedback quality, the opinions of media studies students often highlight its direct impact on their motivation and educational growth. Students appreciate feedback that is rich in detail and perfectly relevant to their submitted work. Comments that feel abrupt or rude can deeply affect their enthusiasm, sometimes questioning the value of their efforts. Similarly, feedback that seems to talk down to students or is too generic lacks the impact that encourages meaningful learning and personal development. To address these points, it is important for staff to provide feedback that is thoughtfully tailored to reflect the specifics of each assignment or project. Using simple phrases and focusing on the positives along with areas for improvement can make a considerable difference in how students receive and react to feedback. Another effective approach lies in practising consistent and balanced feedback across different modules and tasks. This ensures that students receive a steady, understandable set of guidelines to follow, which is especially important in a subject as subjective as media studies. Through a process of continuous review and adopting clear, respectful communication, institutions can greatly enhance the quality of feedback, making it a tool for positive reinforcement and significant academic advancement.

Feedback Consistency and Assessment Marking

Discussing 'Feedback Consistency and Assessment Marking' unveils the varied experiences media studies students encounter across different modules. Students often express concerns about the consistency of the feedback they receive. Inconsistencies can stem from different staff members having varied interpretations of assessment criteria, which can lead to confusion and a decrease in trust in the marking process. For students to fully trust and engage with their feedback, it is key that they perceive this process as fair and transparent. This issue underscores the importance of a standardised rubric within media studies courses that all staff members adhere to. Having such a standard not only simplifies the marking process but also ensures that students understand exactly what is expected of them and how they can achieve higher grades. Furthermore, consistent feedback aids students in forming a clear idea of their progress and areas needing improvement. Thus, media studies departments must look into setting up systems and training that enhance the uniformity of feedback and foster a more equitable learning environment. By focusing on improving consistency, institutions advance the trustworthiness and effectiveness of their educational process, allowing students to navigate their academic careers with more confidence and insight.

University and Course Experience

Feedback stands as an important ingredient in the process of media studies education. This is not just about pointing out what students are doing right or wrong, but it’s integral to their entire university process, affecting their satisfaction and engagement with the course. As we looked into students' experiences during the pandemic, it became clear that feedback—both its presence and quality—significantly influenced how they perceived their education process. During such an uncertain time, prompt and constructive feedback provided a sense of continuity and support. Staff need to consider the emotive as well as the educational impact of their feedback. For media studies students, who often engage in creatively demanding tasks, receiving timely and clear feedback not only helps in refining their skills but also boosts their motivation. This encouragement is essential as students adapt to the changing demands of media-related careers. Institutions must look at feedback as a tool that is as integral to learning as lectures and textbooks. A process that supports ongoing dialogue between student and teacher can transform the educational experience, making it more adaptive and engaging, whilst catering to the specific needs of media studies students.

Communication and Interaction

In discussing the communication challenges faced by media studies students concerning feedback, it becomes apparent that delays and inconsistencies often hinder their learning outcomes. Effective communication is key in ensuring that feedback serves its purpose as a constructive tool. When students need to wait for extended periods or encounter different messages from various lecturers, the process becomes less about learning and more about deciphering the feedback itself. Facilitating a smooth flow of consistent information helps students understand and apply their feedback effectively, which is essential for their academic growth and satisfaction.

Student surveys frequently highlight the importance of ongoing interaction between students and staff. This sustained dialogue allows for clearer understanding and adjustment of feedback based on individual needs. Courses in media studies, where projects and assignments are ongoing, especially benefit from an active exchange of ideas and suggestions. Institutions should, therefore, give priority to establishing straightforward, regular communication channels that enable students to feel supported and well-guided throughout their academic process. Embedding this kind of communication culture not only enhances student learning but also fosters a more inclusive and supportive educational environment.

Concluding Thoughts

To summarise, feedback in media studies courses is not just a tool for academic assessment but a vital bridge between student learning experiences and educational enhancements. The insights gathered from media studies students across various UK universities highlight the need for prompt, clear, and consistent feedback processes. These responses are pivotal in shaping a supportive educational framework that is receptive to student needs and focused on continual improvement. Institutions have the opportunity to look into evolving their feedback systems to become more aligned with the dynamic nature of media studies. By adopting simple strategies such as the use of straightforward language, timely responses, and maintaining consistency across various staff members, the feedback can truly serve its intended purpose—enriching student learning and boosting their academic confidence. As institutions continue starting these important changes, they can significantly improve not only the academic outcomes but also the overall student engagement and satisfaction. Looking forward, it is key that this dialogue between students and staff remains open, active, and geared towards refining the effectiveness of feedback in media studies education.

More posts on feedback:

More posts on media studies student views: