Mental health nursing students' perspectives on feedback

By Student Voice
feedbackmental health nursing

Introduction

In recent years, the importance of feedback in the area of higher education has become more clear, especially for those involved in mental health nursing programmes. This blog post aims to look into the intricate aspects of feedback through the lens of mental health nursing students. We focus on various elements such as the timing, consistency, and quality of feedback students receive from their institutions. Understanding how feedback is perceived and implemented can significantly enhance educational strategies and support student learning effectively. Engaging with tools like student surveys, text analysis, and actively listening to the student voice within these institutions can offer invaluable insights into how feedback methods are perceived, with the potential to radically change them for the better. Through this we start an ongoing process to optimise and refine feedback methods, making them more tailored and constructive for student learners in this important part of healthcare education.

Challenges with Delayed Feedback

Delayed feedback presents a set of unique challenges in the arena of mental health nursing education. When students receive their results, feedback, or marks belatedly, it can significantly disrupt their learning process and mental well-being. Timely feedback is important to effectively guide students in understanding where their strengths and weaknesses lie, helping them to prepare adequately for future assessments. Without this, students may feel left in the dark, struggling to pinpoint areas needing improvement before moving on to new topics or subsequent exams. The delay also can create a barrier to maintaining momentum and motivation within their studies, which is especially important in a demanding field like mental health nursing.

Frequent and punctual feedback can reaffirm the students' understanding and provide them with clear guidance on how to better their practical and academic skills. Furthermore, incorporating the student voice in assessing the timeliness of feedback could help institutions to see the real-time impact of their feedback processes. By doing so, it ensures the feedback is not only immediate but also reflective of the students’ ongoing needs and circumstances. This can prevent feelings of being overwhelmed and ensures that feedback serves its purpose—to aid in the educational and personal growth of the student.

Consistency Issues in Feedback and Marking

A key concern for mental health nursing students is the experience of inconsistent feedback and varying marking standards. Students often report confusion when different staff members provide contradictory comments or apply diverse criteria for assessments, which can considerably impede their understanding of course expectations and their own development. This inconsistency not only frustrates students but may also hinder their confidence, making it harder to grasp key learning outcomes. To address this, it's imperative for institutions to standardise their feedback process and ensure that all staff are well-aligned with a coherent set of assessment guidelines. Engaging with the student voice here also proves beneficial. By actively embracing feedback from students about their educational experience, institutions can gain actionable insights into where discrepancies lie and what steps are needed to harmonise marking schemes and feedback styles. This transparent approach also fosters a supportive learning environment, where students feel their input is valued and considered in shaping the educational process. Regular training sessions for staff might also be a practical step towards minimising variability in feedback, thereby nurturing a more predictable and supportive educational atmosphere for future mental health professionals.

Importance of Constructive Criticism

Feedback plays an important role in shaping the skills and knowledge of mental health nursing students. It is important to look at how feedback, particularly constructive criticism, is delivered within these academic settings. Students in this field often face emotionally intense situations and require feedback that not only highlights their strengths but also constructively addresses areas needing improvement. Constructive criticism is beneficial as it promotes personal and professional growth by providing specific, clear guidance on what students are doing well and what they can improve. This feedback must be framed positively, fostering an environment where students are encouraged to see growth opportunities rather than view criticism defensively. For educators, offering balanced feedback involves recognising the student’s efforts and framing suggestions for improvement in a way that is supportive and enabling. By including examples and actionable advice, educators can ensure their feedback is practical and relevant to the students' future professional roles. Investing time in offering personalised, detailed feedback demonstrates to students that their educational and personal development is taken seriously by their institution. This form of feedback equips students with the necessary tools and confidence to advance their skills, critical for their success in the dynamic and often challenging field of mental health nursing.

Impact of COVID-19 on Academic Support

The COVID-19 pandemic has greatly changed the way academic support is provided, especially in terms of feedback for mental health nursing students. With the rapid shift to online learning, institutions had to quickly adapt their feedback mechanisms to suit this new mode of delivery. One important aspect of this adaptation has been the increased reliance on digital tools to communicate feedback. While this can offer speed and convenience, it has also led to challenges such as ensuring that feedback remains personalised and meaningful in a virtual setting. The process of giving detailed and insightful feedback is key to student learning and satisfaction. Additionally, the shift online has brought about a need for staff to enhance their digital communication skills to maintain the effectiveness of their feedback. This situation has underscored the importance of feedback in the academic support system, highlighting that it is not just about the content of feedback but also how and when it is delivered. Training sessions for staff have become more frequent, focusing on how to optimally use online platforms for feedback purposes. This ongoing process is crucial to ensure that feedback continues to fulfil its role in guiding and enhancing the education of future mental health professionals during these challenging times.

Importance of Efficient University Administrative Support

The effectiveness of university administrative support is absolutely important in the context of managing the feedback system for mental health nursing students. Efficient administrative processes can drastically improve how feedback is handled, ensuring that it is both timely and relevant. For instance, when administrative staff efficiently manage the process of collecting and distributing feedback, students receive their assessments swiftly, enabling them to make use of this critical input without unnecessary delays. This timeliness is key in helping students address areas of concern, enhance their knowledge, and prepare confidently for future challenges.\n\nAdministrative clarity is equally important in the smooth operation of feedback mechanisms. Miscommunications can often lead to frustrations, causing students to feel undervalued or misunderstood. To prevent this, it's imperative that administrative communications are clear, direct, and considerate, carrying the student voice throughout the process. By making sure that the feedback loop is transparent and direct, universities can foster a supportive environment where students trust that their views and educational needs are being considered. This trust is fundamental in nurturing a positive educational experience and encouraging active participation from mental health nursing students in their educational journeys.

Role of Personal Tutors in Feedback Processes

The involvement of personal tutors in the feedback process is fundamentally important in nurturing the academic and emotional well-being of mental health nursing students. Personal tutors play a key role in providing personalised and constructive feedback that can greatly influence a student's learning journey. They act as a bridge between the students and the broader educational system, making sure that feedback not only addresses academic performance but also supports the students' mental health needs.

Effective communication from personal tutors ensures that feedback is clear, timely, and relevant, empowering students to address any academic challenges promptly. This personal touch helps in building a trusting relationship, wherein students feel comfortable discussing sensitive issues, thus enhancing the overall educational experience. Additionally, the insights gathered from student surveys can assist personal tutors in tailoring their feedback to better meet individual student needs and preferences.

Through regular and meaningful interactions, personal tutors can facilitate a continuous dialogue about performance and expectations, which is essential in the complex and demanding field of mental health nursing. This ongoing engagement helps students remain motivated and informed about their progress, crucial for their academic success and personal development.

Feedback within Practical Placements

Practical placements are a key part of learning for mental health nursing students, offering real-world experience that is crucial for their professional development. During these placements, the role of feedback becomes significantly pronounced, influencing not only the student's skill improvement but also their confidence and ability to apply theoretical knowledge in practical situations. In this light, the consistency and quality of feedback provided during placements are of utmost importance.

Students often find themselves working in a variety of settings, from hospitals to community clinics, where the type of feedback can vary greatly depending on the supervising staff. It is important that all supervisors follow a clear and standardised approach to delivering feedback. This includes providing timely, specific, and constructive comments that students can use to hone their skills. Furthermore, using simple language and practical examples can help demystify complex clinical situations, making the learning process more accessible and engaging. By integrating text analysis tools, institutions can look into the feedback content to ensure it aligns well with educational standards and addresses the student's personal learning needs.

The incorporation of consistent, constructive feedback within placements helps bridge the gap between classroom learning and field practice, affording students a smoother transition into professional roles. Regular and thoughtful feedback during these placements nurtures a supportive learning environment, crucial for students when they face the inevitable challenges of real-world mental health care.

More posts on feedback:

More posts on mental health nursing student views: